One human. Real ears. No algorithms.

Get honest human feedback on your unfinished tracks.

A real producer listens and tells you what's working, what to finish, and the single best moment to build around.

Subscribe — €9.99/month

Or claim a free feedback slot below — first 5 tracks this week only.

About the reviewer

Reviewed by Big City — official sound designer for Novation Circuit Tracks.

Live credits alongside Frank Wiedemann (Âme / Innervisions) and Matthew Herbert.

Signed artist on Petite Victory Collective ↗

@bigcitystudios on Instagram ↗

This week only

The first 5 tracks this week
get honest human feedback, free.

No credits, no algorithms. Drop your email and we'll follow up with instructions to send your track. Slots reset each week — this keeps things real and lets us keep doing it. After your free one, the monthly subscription is there if you want ongoing feedback.

5 slots this week

How it works

Three steps. No mystery.

STEP 01

Drop your track

Send whatever you're working on — rough mix, half-finished idea, not-ready-yet demo. No polish required.

STEP 02

Real ears on it

The founder personally sits down and listens. No bots, no interns, no rubrics. Just honest human attention.

STEP 03

Honest notes + your timestamp

Written feedback on what's working and why — plus your single best moment flagged with a timestamp.

Sample feedback

Here's what you actually get back.

Untitled_Collab_v4.wav

REVIEWED ✓

There's a real idea here. The pads in the intro have a ton of atmosphere — you've let them breathe, which most producers rush past. The drop at 1:48 loses some of that energy though; the kick needs more room to hit. The second-verse vocal chop feels slightly disconnected from the intro vibe — could be intentional, but worth sitting with.

Best Moment

1:14

“The bass hits right as the vocal chop comes in. This is your hook — everything before it should be building to this moment.”

Reviewed by: Big City· Sent within 72h· Written, not automated

Why EarShot

Not a credit platform.

Groover sells submission credits. Curators might listen — or might not. You get a thumbs up or a vague hope someone adds you to a playlist. That's not feedback. That's a lottery.

OTHER PLATFORMS

EARSHOT

Pay per submission, no guaranteed listen

€9.99/month — every track gets heard

Vague feedback or none at all

Written notes on what's working and what to fix

Playlist promises, stream counts

No playlists. No streams. Just honest feedback.

Curator decides if they're interested

You always get a reply within 72h

Built to find curators, not give feedback

One listen. One honest take.

Common questions

What you need to know.

Who is this for?

Independent producers who want an honest, human opinion on unfinished tracks before they finish, release, or play them live.

What do I get each month?

Submit up to 5 tracks. Big City listens, picks the 1–2 strongest, explains why — originality and creative potential over technical polish — and flags the single best moment with a timestamp.

Can I cancel anytime?

Yes. Cancel anytime, no questions asked. Your first track is reviewed free — no credit card needed for the free review.

Ready to send
your track?

Submit up to 5 tracks a month. Big City listens to every one, writes reviews for the strongest 1–2, and flags your best moment with a timestamp.

Cancel anytime. First track reviewed free. No credit card needed for the free review.